Farve vs Brady

[miamidolphin4life]

Since it's pretty obvious that on these boards Tom Brady sucks and isn't really that good. I will no longer try to argue for him. So lets go to the next matchup. Who'd you guys say is the better QB. And yes this is career wise

[giantsfan6017]

Brett still has all the records

[Leelee2]

While I'd rather have Brady on my team now... Favre has had the better career. Other than 2007, Brady's never been the best at his position and there's a fair argument that most of his success is due to Mr. Belichick's genius. Favre has had MVP caliber seasons on 3 completely different offenses.

[wraith36444]

I would take a guy who is clutch as opposed to a guy who turns into Nate Kaeding in a big game.

[piazzajordan2]

Tom Brady.

[SanchoPanza]

Tom Brady. Best there is, best there was, best there ever will be

[PaddyPatriot]

I liked Walt's point about how back in 07 Brady was the most motivated QB in the league, he lived to win and his hatred of losing was his competitive advantage.

unfortunately it seems like he has a lot of other stuff going on now. I still think he can regain his form and disprove the doubters

[big blue monster]

Tom Brady. Best there is, best there was, best there ever will be

Yeah OK. ( a little delusional ) If the Colts win the SB , that title will change for sure.
anyway , back on track.......Favre is proven better than Brady.

[studbucket]

So this is a tough question. Assuming Tom Brady continues his current career trajectory (no reason he wouldn't; QBs don't start sucking at age 30 like RBs), I would choose him over Favre. After 8 seasons, the numbers are about the same, as are All-Pros and Pro Bowls. If Brady played 18 seasons, his numbers would be very close to Favre's, but his winning % is much higher, as are his SBs.

[GoBlue11]

Tom Brady= Michigan
Michigan= No.1

Therefore, I conlude...
Tom Brady= No.1

Math RULEZ!

[Colts Homer]

I'll take the guy with the better QB rating and AY/A in the playoffs. He plays for Minnesota right now.