Trade I was offered

[Trips]

Hey guys, i need some help. I have been offered a trade and I would like to know if I should make it. The deal is Selvin Young and Kurt Warner for DeAngelo Williams. I have Aaron rogers and Tom Brady at qb and with brady done for the year I picked up Trent Edwards off waivers.

Should I take this deal and if so what do i do with edwards at qb? Thanks for the advice.

[wraith36444]

edawrds isnt a bad qb in real life but he has dick jauron AKA Herman Edwards of the east as his coach...which means not too many big games.

Warner has fitz and boldin to throw to and williams is not a big fantasy option.

Boils down to 2 things:

Do you have faith in Rogers?

Do you have decent other RB options?

If yes to both I do not see why you wouldnt acquire Warner.

[ZN0rseman]

I don't like that trade unless he includes, or you already have, Jonathan Stewart. It's only a matter of time before Stewart ousts Williams as the starter, and when he does Willams value will tank and Stewart will be worth his weight in gold. Sure, Young had a terrible game against Oakland but I'm still not convinced that Shanahan is going to give him that few carries this season. It doesn't make sense when you've got got a bona-fide stud RB like Young riding the pine. Also, I think Rodgers is going to be solid, so Warner doesn't bring a lot to the table for you (other than eating up a valuable roster spot) and he's certainly an an injury risk.

[Adam Mac]

If you're giving up D Williams I like the trade to get Warner and S. Young