+ Reply to Thread
Page 3 of 8
FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 ... LastLast
Results 21 to 30 of 72

Thread: Be The GM - Depth Charts/Grading Discussion

  1. Join Date
    Jan 2010

    Baltimore Ravens

    QB: Joe Flacco / Tyrod Taylor
    RB: Ray Rice / Anthony Allen / Jeff Demps
    FB: Laron McClain
    WR:Anquan Boldin / Tandon Doss / LaQuan Williams
    WR: Greg Childs / Torrey Smith
    TE: Ed Dickson / Dennis Pitta
    LT: Ryan Clady
    LG: Michael Oher / Lucas Nix
    C: Matt Birk
    RG:Andre Gurode / Justin Boren
    RT: Bryant McKinnie / Jah Reid

    LE: Pernell McPhee
    NT: Terrance Cody /
    RE: Haloti Ngata / Aurthur Jones
    LOLB: Keith Rivers / Sergio Kindle / Chandler Jones
    LILB: Ray Lewis / Zach Brown
    RILB: Jameel McClain
    ROLB: Terrell Suggs / Paul Kruger
    CB: Jimmy Smith / Cliff Harris / Carey Williams
    CB: Antonio Cromartie / Chykie Brown
    S: Ed Reed / Brandon Taylor
    S: Antrel Rolle / Bernard Pollard

    PK Billy Cundiff
    P Sam Koch
    PR Jeff Demps
    KR Cliff Harris
    LS Morgan Cox

    The Baltimore Ravens D with have multiple looks with multiple personnel. It will go from 3-4 to 4-6 for base D. The future past 2013 looks bright. I have added several younger players to get experience from Ed Reed and Ray Lewis. I think they will have a great mental impact on the younger guys I am bringing in. I still have hope that Sergio can get his career on track and become a solid rush backer. This year I will rotate a lot of players opposite of Suggs until one shakes to the top. I added Keith Rivers to compete at OLB this year and possibly move inside next year. This all depends on where Zach Brown and Chandler Jones best fits. Zach Brown has the athletic ability to be a monster in the NFL. His speed alone could cause mismatches rushing the QB. So moving people around to see where they fit most comfortably will be done. I also see Paul Kruger coming in and adding to last years contributions. LB is very deep for the Ravens. I am looking for big things out of Rolle this year. I believe he will have a better chance of playing up to his pay in the Ravens aggressive D.

    On O I made some changes to the Oline. Some of which brought be heat. Good cause I believe I made our Oline even better than last years oline. I brought in a top LT moving McKinnie to RT just gave me a top set of tackles. Oher was a good Rt but I expect him to be an All Pro LG. Birk is the most underrated center in the league. RG is the only question mark I have on the Oline but I believe I have the right people to make it a smooth transition. LT and WR were to big needs on the Ravens O. I got great value in Childs. His knee is getting stronger and if not for the injury he would have been gone as high as the second but third for sure. Although I like the direction Smith is going I still think he needs more time to polish his skills.

    Chandler Jones is # 16 on scouts inc top 32 BB. Over the years I have watch and compared BB's to see who's are the more accurate. Scouts Inc generally hits the spot with there BB's. Zach Brown is not in the top 32 but he was. They have him graded at a 89. which is fringe first round gone early in round 2. They are the only people to have Tyson Aluala in the top 32. This BB is based off talent potential and the buzz coming from nfl scouts on certain players.
    Last edited by rudsdog55; 04-22-2012 at 08:35 PM.
    Putting the D back in Minnesota

  2. Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Fort Wayne IN

    Kansas City Chiefs

    QB-Matt Cassel / Rick Stanzi / Kellen Moore
    RB- Jamaal Charles / Trent Richardson
    APB- Dexter Mccluster
    FB/H-Back- Peyton Hillis
    WR- Dwayne Bowe / Derek Moye
    WR- Jonathan Baldwin / Steve Breston / Jerheme Urban
    TE- Tony Moeaki / Steve Maneri
    LT- Brandon Albert
    LG- Kelechi Osemele / Ryan Lilja
    C- Rodney Hudson
    RG- Jon Asomuga / Ryan Lilja
    RT- Eric Winston

    DE- Glenn Dorsey / Allen Bailey
    NT- Josh Chapman / Jerry Powe / Anthony Toribio
    DE- Tyson Jackson / Trevor Guyton / Wallace Gilberry
    OLB- Tamba Hali / Cameron Sheffield
    ILB- Derrick Johnson / Brandon Siler
    ILB- Tank Carder / Jovan Belcher
    OLB- Justin Houston / Andy Studebaler / Gabe Miller
    CB- Brandon Flowers / Javier Arenas
    CB- Stanford Route / Jalil Brown / Donnie Fletcher
    FS- Kendrick Lewis
    SS- Eric Berry

    Draft Selections:
    1 (11). Trent Richardson
    2 (44). Kelechi Osemele
    3 (74). Josh Chapman
    4 (107). Tank Carder
    5 (146). Trevor Guyton
    6 (182). Donnie Fletcher
    7 (218). Derek Moye
    7 (238). Kellen Moore
    Last edited by Snake; 04-22-2012 at 09:35 PM.

  3. Join Date
    Nov 2010
    In your head

    Miami Dolphins

    Offensive Starters

    QB Matt Moore
    RB Reggie Bush
    FB Charles Clay
    WRs Santanna Moss, Brian Hartline, and Devone Bess (Slot)
    TE Anthony Fasano
    LT Jake Long
    LG Mike Pouncey
    C Michael Brewster
    RG John Jerry
    RT Andrew Datko

    Defensive Starters

    DE DWight Freeney and Robert Mathis
    DT Pual Solia and Jared Odrick
    OLB Karlos Dansby and Travis Lewis
    ILB Luke Kuechly
    CBs Vontae Davis, Sean Smith, and Richard Marshall (Nickle/FS)
    SS Reshad Jones
    FS Jimmy Wilson

    Special Teams

    Kicker Dan Carpenter
    Punter Brandon Fields
    Long Snapper John Denney


    QB David Garard and Brock Oswieler
    RB Daniel Thomas and Steve Slaton
    WRs Clyde Gates and Chris Rainey
    TEs Jeron Mastrud and Les Brown
    OTs Lyndon Murtha and Nate garner
    OGs Artis Hicks, Ritchie Incognito, and Rey Fienga

    DEs Philip Merling and Ryan Baker
    DTs Tony McDaniel
    OLBs Kevin Burnett, Gary Guyton, and Jamal Westerman
    ILBs Vontaze Burfict and Austin Spitler
    CBs Nolan Carroll
    Safeties Tyrone Culver, Chris Clemons, Janzen Jackson, and Tyrell Johnson

    Expect Rainey and Bush on the field at the same time about 10 plays a game. Gates will also see time to strech the field. This offense will be explosive and the D is approved and now converted from 3-4 to 4-3. In Dime sets I will move Jimmy Wilson to CB and Janzen Jackson will go to FS.

    Green= Rookies
    Red = Trades
    Last edited by JoeLegend; 04-21-2012 at 05:29 AM.

  4. Join Date
    Feb 2011

    Indianapolis Colts

    QB: Andrew Luck, Drew Stanton
    RB: Donald Brown, Cyrus Gray, Delone Carter, Darren Evans
    FB: Chris Gronkowski
    WR: Tommy Streeter, Nick Toon, Dwight Jones, Donnie Avery
    Slot WR: Austin Collie
    TE: Dwayne Allen, Rob Housler, Brody Eldridge
    TE/H-back: Michael Egnew

    LT: Anthony Castonzo
    LG: Joe Reitz, Matt McGlynn, Adam Gettis
    C: Samson Satele, Matt McGlynn, Jake Kirkpatrick, Adam Gettis
    RG: Ben Ijalana, Seth Olsen, Matt McGlynn
    RT: Jeff Linkenbach, Winston Justice

    LDE: Frank Alexander, Tim Fugger
    NT: Alameda Ta'amu, Antonio Johnson, Brandon McKinney
    UT: Drake Nevis, Fili Moala
    RDE: Shea McClellin, Jerry Hughes
    SLB: Kavell Conner, Jerrell Freeman
    MLB: Pat Angerer
    WLB: Gerald McRath, AJ Edds

    CB1: Jerraud Powers
    CB2: Leonard Johnson
    Nickel CB: Chris Rucker
    CBs: Kevin Thomas, Coty Sensabaugh
    SS: Tom Zibikowski, David Caldwell, Joe Lefeged
    FS: Rahim Moore, Mike Newton

    K: Adam Vinatieri
    P: Pat McAfee
    LS: Justin Snow
    KR/PR: Cyrus Gray
    ST: Tim Fugger

    Bold indicates rookie, underline indicates new addition

    1.1 Andrew Luck, QB Stanford
    2.2 Alameda Ta'amu NT, Washington
    2.3 Dwayne Allen TE, Clemson
    2.10 Shea McClellin, DE/OLB/MLB, Boise State
    3.1 Leonard Johnson CB, Iowa St.
    3.28 Tommy Streeter WR, Miami
    4.2 Nick Toon WR, Wisconsin
    4.3 Cyrus Gray RB, Texas A&M
    4.24 Dwight Jones WR, UNC
    5.1 Michael Egnew TE, Missouri
    5.35 Frank Alexander DE, Oklahoma
    6.37 Tim Fugger DE/OLB, Vanderbilt
    7.7 Coty Sensabaugh CB, Clemson
    7.46 Adam Gettis G/C, Iowa
    Last edited by Jwarr37; 04-23-2012 at 01:42 PM.
    Boston Celtics 2013 NBA CMD Champions

    CMD Picks: 11.16, 12.10, 13.21, 14.10, 14.15, 15.21, 16.10, 17.21, 19.21, 20.10, 21.21, 22.10

  5. Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Under the bridge

    Damn. That's a pretty bare roster. You've done a great job at cleaning the old and injecting the young. 3 years away from competing though imo.

  6. Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Under the bridge

    I'll post my complete depth chart after the draft finishes.

  7. Join Date
    Feb 2011

    Quote Originally Posted by Lukic View Post
    Damn. That's a pretty bare roster. You've done a great job at cleaning the old and injecting the young. 3 years away from competing though imo.
    Oh definetley it's a ways away from competing. I really love my start though, adding 4 potential starters to the defense, grabbing my franchise QB, and surrounding him with a ton of weapons. Probably two drafts and Luck's development away from competing though.
    Boston Celtics 2013 NBA CMD Champions

    CMD Picks: 11.16, 12.10, 13.21, 14.10, 14.15, 15.21, 16.10, 17.21, 19.21, 20.10, 21.21, 22.10

  8. I figure the Bears are going to get more physical on offense with the signing of Michael Bush so I picked up Cordy Glenn to push people around and Orson Charles as another safety valve for Cutler who generally held onto the ball too long in Mike Martz' offense. Josh Morgan should help things out if Johnny Knox doesn't return to form for one reason or another.

    Coples seems like a good fit on defense for the Bears. In general, the pass rushers on my Bears roster are all massive and I figure that Coples potential is somewhere between Peppers and Idonije and should fit in perfectly.

    QB: Jay Cutler, Jason Campbell
    RB: Matt Forte, Michael Bush, Kahlil Bell
    TE: Orson Charles, Kellen Davis, Matt Spaeth
    WR: Brandon Marshall, Johnny Knox, Devin Hester, Josh Morgan, Devin Thomas, Earl Bennett
    OT: Cordy Glenn, Gabe Camiri, J'Marcus Webb
    C: Roberto Garza, Edwin Williams
    G: Chilo Rachal, Lance Lewis, Ricky Henry

    DE: Julius Peppers, Quinton Coples, Israel Idonije, Corey Wootton
    DT: Matt Toeaina, Stephen Paea, Henry Melton, Jordan Miller
    LB: Brian Urlacher, Lance Briggs, Geno Hayes, Blake Costanzo, Jabara Williams
    CB: Charles Tillman, Tim Jennings, DJ Moore, Jonathan Wilhte, Asa Jackson
    S: Chris Conte, Major Wright, Winston Guy Jr, Donovan Warren

    ST: Eric Weems
    K: Gould
    P: Podlesh
    Last edited by Mezzanine; 04-21-2012 at 01:23 PM.

  9. Join Date
    Oct 2011

    Rudsdog55, Brandon McKinney no longer plays for you, he signed for the Colts. Also surely if you're moving to the 4-6 you need to change the way that your defence is listed. You also don't have Tom Zbikowski.
    Last edited by jepg; 04-21-2012 at 01:44 PM.

  10. Join Date
    Jul 2011

    Be the GM: Minnesota Vikings

    1.3: Matt Kalil, OT, Southern California
    1.26: Stephen Hill, WR, Georgia Tech
    3.3: Markelle Martin, S, Oklahoma State
    4.33: Senio Kelemete, OG, Washington
    4.39: Shaun Prater, CB, Iowa
    5.3: Ronnie Hillman, RB, San Diego State
    6.5: Terrell Manning, OLB, North Carolina State
    7.3: Damon Harrison, NT, William Penn
    7.16: Micah Pellerin, CB, Hampton
    New additions in italics:

    Offense: (Base package: Singleback 2 TE formation)

    QB: Christian Ponder, Joe Webb, Sage Rosenfels
    RB: Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart, Caleb King, Ronnie Hillman, Jordan Todman, Lex Hillard
    FB: Jerome Felton, Ryan D'Imperio
    WR1: Stephen Hill, Devin Aromashadu, Emmanuel Arceneaeux
    WR2: Percy Harvin, Jerome Simpson, Michael Jenkins, Brian Walters
    WR3: Jerome Simpson, Michael Jenkins, Devin Aromashadu
    (On certain packages, Simpson will flip to WR2 and Harvin will play Slot)
    TE: Kyle Rudolph, John Carlson, Mickey Shuler, Allen Reisner
    LT: Matt Kalil
    LG: Charlie Johnson, Senio Kelemete
    C: John Sullivan, Brandon Fusco, Joe Berger
    RG: Geoff Schwartz, Chris DeGeare
    RT: Phil Loadholt, DeMarcus Love

    Defense (4-3 base):

    RE: Everson Griffen, Brian Robison
    DT: Kevin Williams, Christian Ballard
    NT/DT2: Letroy Guion, Christian Ballard, Fred Evans, Damon Harrison
    LE: Jared Allen, D'Aundre Reed
    SLB: Chad Greenway, Larry Dean
    MLB: Jasper Brinkley, Terrell Manning, Tyrone McKenzie
    WLB: Erin Henderson, Terrell Manning, Soloman Elimimian
    CB1: Chris Cook, Zackary Bowman, Brandon Burton, Asher Allen,
    CB2: Chris Carr, Shaun Prater, Marcus Sherels, Micah Pellerin
    CB3: Shaun Prater
    FS: Markelle Martin, Jamarca Sanford
    SS: Antoine Winfield, Mistral Raymond

    K: Ryan Longwell
    P: Chris Kluwe


    Alright, I don't think I did that bad of a job. It was a solid draft for the Vikings even though people said that I reached on some players. I got a special athlete in Stephen Hill who has uncanny speed, size and jumping ability. While some fans say that he reminds them or Troy Williamson I disagree. Hill has the intangibles needed to succeed at WR and it gives Ponder a big target to throw at between the 20's. Ponder was incredibly efficient in the red-zone last year and keeping most the targets he had last year will improve or at least maintain that. Rudolph and Carlson will create some unique matchups in the 2 TE sets. Hill and Harvin are arguably one of the fastest pair of WRs in the NFL. Harvin along with Rudolph will be nice targets within 10 yards of the LOS. Hill can stretch deep.

    Pass protection is much improved from the previous year. Ponder finally has a blindside protector that is able to give him time to drop back in the pocket. If Charlie Johnson is unable to pan out at LG (where he played some good years) then Senio Kelemete is a nice plug and play down the road towards weeks 10-12 when he knows the offense. Geoff Schwartz was a big addition in FA and gives a legitimate side of the field for Peterson to run behind. The protection is going to be way better than it was last year.


    The defensive line is pretty well, although I would have liked to make an addition to the NT spot. I can still do that on round 7 or potentially in UDFA or in FA. The linebacking corps get a significant addition with Terrell Manning. Manning is a versatile linebacker who can play the Mike or Will. He will push both Erin Henderson and Jasper Brinkley to play good in order to keep their jobs. Henderson is on a one year contract that is a "prove it" contract, if he is able to play at a high level then Manning can be switched to Mike.

    The secondary has been completely revamped. Winfield moves to strong safety where he can play the run most of the time, he is an excellent in the box defender and blitzer. Markelle Martin is the type of safety that the Vikings have needed for a very long time. He is a rangy safety that can make good plays by tackling and deflecting passes. He is not an interception machine but a good enough player to cause game changing plays. The Vikings secondary had problems last year with opponents because of poor safety play. Winfield can easily be a top 10 strong safety from the time he starts playing the position and Martin can be at least a good player that makes underrated plays.

    The cornerback position mainly got filled through FA. Chris Cook is able to play with the team again and that is really good news for the Vikings. Cook has showed flashes of greatness at times and then flashes of incompetence at others. However, he can become the #1 CB that is able to shut down opposing receivers with a unique combination of speed, aggressive play, technique and size. His size will give other tall, physical WR's fits (Calvin Johnson). Chris Carr is a serviceable CB that will pave the way for Shaun Prater to get his opportunity to play at that position. Prater was a good scheme fit and one of the top CB's available at the end of the 4th round. Unless the Vikings switch from the cover 2 scheme, Prater was an excellent fit for the defense.
    Last edited by Pain; 04-24-2012 at 01:52 PM.

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts