The "Who Should I Start?" Thread

[Swaggy]

PPR flex: Decker vs BAL or Sproles vs ATL?

Also, NYJ's Def vs TEN or MIA vs JAX

[Panda with issues...]

Playoff semis. It could be the end of the line for my team.

My opposition has Lynch, Charles, Brandon Marshall, Megatron, and is solid everywhere except QB, number 1 seed in the league. I think I just have to put out my best possible team and hope that they have a big day.

My options:

Brady @SF

Gore vs NE
Alfred Morris @Cle

Julio Jones vs NYG
Andre Johnson vs IND
Danario Alexander vs CAR (FLEX)
Dallas Clark @NO

+Jason Hanson and CHI D/ST

Other options:

Wilson @BUF

Dwyer@DAL
D. Wilson @ATL

Miles Austin vsPIT
Blackmon @MIA
Dwayne Allen @HOU

Any thoughts? Glaringly bad starts?

[Michigan Mike]

PPR format flex start:

Mike Williams (TB), David Wilson or Mikel Leshoure.

[pheltzbahr]

PPR format flex start:

Mike Williams (TB), David Wilson or Mikel Leshoure.

With Bradshaw out, that should make Wilson the best choice.

Speaking of Wilson, he's suddenly made RBs an embarrassment of riches for 2 of my Playoff squads.

Pick 2 (AP is my other RB)

Knowshonn @BAL
Wilson @ATL
McFadden vsKC

Pick 3 (WF Dynasty League Semis)

TRich vsWAS
Alf Morris @CLE
CJ2K vsJETS
Wilson @ATL

[miamidolphin4life]

Pick One
Vernon Davis vs Patriots
Greg Olsen vs Chargers

Pick One
J.Bell(Lions) vs Cardinals
Turner(ATL) vs Giants
M.Owens(JAX) vs Dolphins

Pick One
Brandon Myers(OAK) vs Chiefs
Owen Daniels(HOU) vs Colts

With Bradshaw out, that should make Wilson the best choice.

Speaking of Wilson, he's suddenly made RBs an embarrassment of riches for 2 of my Playoff squads.

Pick 2 (AP is my other RB)

Knowshonn @BAL
Wilson @ATL
McFadden vsKC

Pick 3 (WF Dynasty League Semis)

TRich vsWAS
Alf Morris @CLE
CJ2K vsJETS
Wilson @ATL

Knowshonn and Wilson.

TRich
Wilson

You know how good the Jets are against the run, so you can make the decision between him and Morris.

[Michigan Mike]

Week 16 Defense:

Washington @ Philly
or
Arizona vs Chicago

I love the Redskins matchup against Philly, but they have been lackluster most of the year. Arizona has been pretty solid fantasy wise and is coming off a raping of the Lions. What do you guys think?

[Alastair]

Week 16 Defense:

Washington @ Philly
or
Arizona vs Chicago

I love the Redskins matchup against Philly, but they have been lackluster most of the year. Arizona has been pretty solid fantasy wise and is coming off a raping of the Lions. What do you guys think?

I had the same options and I'm going with the Redskins. The Eagles have just been a turnover machine lately. It's like the ball gets greased before the games or something. Shady is back, so that might hurt the value a little bit, but Foles isn't really threatening in the passing game, so that could be limited. There's a great chance that Arizona will put up huge points on Chicago, but the Bears are really streaky on offense. Some days they commit a dozen turnovers and look like hell, the next week against a stronger opponent, they'll put up 40 points. I think the risk/reward is higher with Arizona, but the Redskins are a safer pick. I would analyze your other players versus your opponent. If you're facing someone really strong that you may not be able to beat, take the gamble with Arizona. If you're more evenly matched and the defense won't be the deciding factor, I'd go with the Skins.

[Panda with issues...]

For the championship:

Set apart from flex:

Options:

M. Austin @NO
Danario Alexander vs NYJ

other options:

Jonathan Dwyer vs CIN
David Wilson@BAL

I don't like either of the running backs here, and I'm leaning towards Austin. The New Orleans game is going to be a shootout, and the jets pass D still seems fairly solid. Alexander obviously has the higher upside, but he laid a 0 on me in my semi match up, which I was lucky to survive. Austin is probably solid for 6-10 points or so, and I think overall my team is better than the opposition

[sebennayx]

Nicks @ BAL or Ridley @ JAC for my flex.

[WildBuckeye]

PPR League

Quarterback:
Robert Griffin or Cam Newton?

Running Back: Pick 2
Matt Forte
Ray Rice
Trent Richardson
Steven Ridely

WR: Pick 2
Hakeem Nicks
Dez Bryant
Vincent Jackson

Flex:Anyone not picked above.

Thanks