New Derek Anderson Trade

[Walter]

Browns Get:

Round 2 Pick 32
Round 2 Pick 59

Dolphins Get:

QB Derek Anderson
NT Ethan Kelly
Round 3 Pick 88
Round 6 Pick 180

[TheOUTLAW1]

Why the heck would Cleveland have to give up picks and Kelley to get 2 second rounders?

The problem is that the majority here are not Browns fans, frankly they are better off not taking the risk of trading him if this is the only crap that they get.

[regoob2]

The 32nd pick is a 1st rounder in any other year and a lot of teams would rather get 2 good players than 1 slightly better player. Anderson is very overrated and the 1st and 3rd tender is just because he's a RFA. The Browns would take 2 2nds for him all day long.

[Matt McGuire]

This trade should not be allowed. Anderson must be traded for a 1st and 3rd or not at all.

[regoob2]

The first and 3rd tender is if someone tries to sign him as a RFA.

[bills_red]

The first and 3rd tender is if someone tries to sign him as a RFA.

Yep, they can trade him for a 7th round pick if they wanted.

[ysuallthetime]

Ehhh. I like the 1st voerall pick in round 2, but I think they would turn this trade down.

[Joey_Potter]

Matt. Im going to say this once, only once. You obviously dont want my defense being better and I obviously know Derek Anderson better than you. So do us a favor because everything you wouldnt do is a joke so vote no and shut up.

[Matt McGuire]

Well when Anderson is tendered you are going to give me some dap.

[Joey_Potter]

Matt, I dont care what these Browns do with him. I saw and dicected every game and broke down his statsThings you obviously havent. I know what he's worth. Also no one in their right mind will give up a 1 and 3 or 2 seconds for him without more. I'm smarter than you think and if Savage gets a 1 and 3 I'll buy him a coke and loby for the firing of the other team's GM.

[RaidaNation]

i say yes.it's pretty tough to be realistic & keep it fair.afterall this i a mock & supposed to fun.as long as it isn't crazy trades, i say let'em all go.

crazy trade IE-7th rd for peyton or 2- 6th rds for a 1st

[TheOUTLAW1]

I have no problem with the Browns getting two seconds for him. It's the fact that they have a third, sixth and Kelley going back the other way. To try to argue my point without taking this into consideration is a bit disengenuous.

[Joey_Potter]

I argue it, and everyone else that call this lopsided and stupid to make this deal because you dont look at the stats or seen all the games like I do and have. Seen every damn one. You people believe too much of the hype and love the highlights on Anderson but dont see the big picture. That is why you vote no.

[TheOUTLAW1]

I disagree. I have watched every down as well and while Anderson isn't perfect he's worth more to the Browns even in a backup role than this. IMO

[NoNonsenseCoach]

It's that 3rd round pick that makes this lopsided to me, but I voted yes anyways. Good luck Browns