Bal-Jax Troy Smith Trade

[Walter]

BAL gets: Jagx 5th(#193)

JAX gets: QB-Troy Smith

[49ersfan]

Guys, Troy Smith is in going into his second year and would not be traded, which is why I voted no. That said, I think the deal is otherwise fine.

[RaidaNation]

the reason jags need a qb is they lack in depth.
Garrard will be next yrs starter but backup Quinn Gray is a UFA & there no one after him on the roster

[regoob2]

^ya but why would the ravens trade its only qb that has any upside.

[RaidaNation]

true.however, i thought this was a mock draft & meant for fun.If this trade goes down some of these others that have passed should have been shot down as well.

[regoob2]

Fine.............. i'll vote yes.

[RaidaNation]

Fine.............. i'll vote yes.

lol, don't make me twist your arm or anything.I'm only being honest here.Over half of these trades would have never gone through.But it's supposed to be fun & fantasy.

[Joey_Potter]

I vote yes just because

[RaidaNation]

Guys, Troy Smith is in going into his second year and would not be traded, which is why I voted no. That said, I think the deal is otherwise fine.

so what.you were gonna trade manny lawson.what does that have to do w/ anything?

[Matt McGuire]

lol why are people disallowing this trade? What is unfair about it? Baltimore invested a 5th into him last year and trade him for a 5th.

Seems fair he sucks anyways.

[RaidaNation]

not that he sucks.but i thought they get back their investment.

[49ersfan]

so what.you were gonna trade manny lawson.what does that have to do w/ anything?

I was going to trade Lawson (a stupid move in hindsight) and I had my trade rejected because Lawson was a young guy. Therefore, this trade shouldn't pass either.

[RaidaNation]

regardless of hindsight.some of the ppl voting said no just b/c they didn't want to see him leave SF.Those votes & reasons weren't credible enough.

[Matt McGuire]

I was going to trade Lawson (a stupid move in hindsight) and I had my trade rejected because Lawson was a young guy. Therefore, this trade shouldn't pass either.

San Francisco made a much bigger investment in Lawson than in Smith. Smith also doesn't have much upside as a QB as opposed to Lawson as an OLB.

[Joey_Potter]

Who knows, Smith could be the next Doug Floutie