Mayock's WR Rankings

[Matt McGuire]

1. Mario Manningham
2. Malcolm Kelly
3. Limas Sweed
4. Devin Thomas
5. Donnie Avery

My problem with this list...NO DESEAN JACKSON?

What's up with that?

[starqb14]

manningham is a cancer.

[Matt McGuire]

Why do you say that?

[animal52]

manningham is a cancer.

I watched him for 3 years. I saw no evidence of that. But, I don't think he's the best in the country.

[bills_red]

Mario Manningham #1, lol

[49ersfan]

That BS. I say Jackson, Kelly, Bowman, Hardy, Doucet

[GridIron NUt]

I think Manningham is better than Doucet. Hes fast and big and has great hands.

[49ersfan]

But he's a locker room cancer.

[starqb14]

manningham is a supreme talent and he knows it. if you watched the badger game you'd have seen how he basically threw mallett into the tank with his little temper tantrums, and then proceeded to drop a couple big time balls later in the game. he might mature out of this if he gets into the right situation, but if he gets a mariucci or denny green then he will for sure be a prima donna.

[Matt McGuire]

There are a lot of players in the NFL that have "spotlight" issues that you don't hear about.

Gruden was talking in training camp how they get Galloway his own room, "Needs his own zip code" he said and how he can be a problem at times.

[starqb14]

hmm. tha's interesting. a great talent for sure. manninghams tantrums would fit great with phil rivers in san diego, because he already doesn't get along with the rest of the team anyway.

[NoNonsenseCoach]

I like Manningham on the list as a 3 or 4... not so much a 1. I think he'll be a great #2 WRer in the NFL. Good deep threat.

He shouldn't be a locker room problem if placed in the right situation.

[Walter]

I can't believe he has Manningham first. Wow.

[Matt McGuire]

Mayock's rankings are usually shockers, but what he does is evaluate the film himself and his track record speaks for himself.

[NoNonsenseCoach]

It's like Bill Belechik... shocks you, but you can't really argue