Matt McGuire's Top 5 Players By Position

[Walter]

Offense - http://walterfootball.com/mattfiveoffense.php

Defense - http://walterfootball.com/mattfivedefense.php

[49ersfan]

Some of them were surprising, but at least I didn't see Quentin Groves.

[NoNonsenseCoach]

No elite offensive prospects? I could see that.

How come you don't have Woodson over Ryan though? Don't you think he's the better QB? Did you make Ryan higher just because he's being drafted first most likely or do you think he's a little better?

I know they got the same 4 star rating, but just curious since Ryan was listed first.

[Matt McGuire]

Because of Andre's inconsistencies with accuracy...also forgot to list Sam Baker as a 4 star ZBS guard.

[jimmyp]

I like it, I'm also getting higher on Flacco. I know its lame, but I was watching that Under Armor senior challenge or whatever its called. He showed pretty good mobility for his size, and his arm is an absolute cannon, 74 yards, I think Matt Ryan was the next best with 67 (of course Woodson wasn't there).

[Matt McGuire]

lol funny you mentioned that...I never watched that dumb All Star challenge...well I did for 3 seconds then when I heard McShay laughing about non-funny "jokes" I switched channel immediately.

[49ersfan]

My QB rankings are as follows (before any one says anything, I know this isn't the order the QBs went in my mock)
1. Ryan
2. Woodson
3. Brohm
4. Henne
5. Flacco

[Joey_Potter]

Red Bryant is at least the 4th best Defensive Tackle, Sedrick Ellis should have 5 Stars, and Chris Long should be #1 Overall pick in the draft. I like the rankings overall.

[Matt McGuire]

Red Bryant is at least the 4th best Defensive Tackle, Sedrick Ellis should have 5 Stars, and Chris Long should be #1 Overall pick in the draft. I like the rankings overall.

There is a difference between extremely good and elite.

Also, where were all these Sedrick Ellis lovers before the Senior Bowl. I was the only one on these forums saying he was one of the top 4-5 players in this draft. If I could give Ellis 4 3/4 stars then I would, but he doesn't get the 5th star because he doesn't have prototypical size and his production was as consistent as it could have been.

There is also really not much of an argument that Bryant is a top 4 DT in this draft, but he can earn a 4th star at the combine...but the combine is where I expect all my top 5 DTs to shine as well so I doubt he moves up.

[NoNonsenseCoach]

I'm not sold on Brohm at #3. He has to prove it again to me

[49ersfan]

Brohm is OK, but Henne is a practice player. Henne may go higher, but he shouldn't.

[Joey_Potter]

I became a Bryant lover after seeing his Bowl game. I saw him run down a running back from behind near the out of bounds line five yards downfield with ease. He did a lot in that game and I loved it all. So mine was well before the Senior Bowl Matt.

[Joey_Potter]

Sedrick Ellis. I listened to you rave about his strengths so much I couldn't help but do my own research. Liked what I saw.

[candyman82]

JDB? Are you kidding?

[49ersfan]

JDB is too fat IMO.