Donovan McNabb: Black QBs are more criticized

[Walter]

Donovan McNabb said on HBO that black QBs are more criticized. He said "I can throw for 300 yards and win the game, but they always ask, 'Why didn't you make this throw?'"

What a weird dude.

I love how he brought up that Peyton Manning and Carson Palmer aren't criticized, yet he didn't mention Rex Grossman, Joey Harrington, Mark Brunell, Brad Johnson, David Carr, Jake Plummer, etc.

All of those guys were more criticized than him.

[TOMMY B]

McNABB WHO ????

LETS SEE , THEY RAN RUSH LIMBAUGH OUT OF TOWN FOR WHAT HE SAID , NOW ITS TIME FOR McNABB TO LEAVE ALSO . HIS SKILLS SO FAR THIS SEASON SEEM TO BE DOWN ALOT FROM PREVIOUS YEARS AND PERHAPS THEY SHOULD HAVE KEPT GARCIA .

IF YOU CANT TAKE THE HEAT McNABB , GET OUT OF THE KITCHEN .

[Matt McGuire]

Yeah, amazing Rush says what he says and gets fired (he deserved it), but McNabb just gets away with what he says and no one cites reverse discrimination.

[Adam Mac]

Peyton Mannington... is he really putting him self on the same level. If McNabb throws for 300 yrds and 4TDs every game then I'm sure he would be praised too. This guy is at the end of his career and he is a joke!

[schmidty]

Donovans careeer numbers are pretty nice, with having 1 year with an amazing reciever. manning has played with Harrision and wayne for the most part, and throw in Dallas Clark. So, Manning does have better targets.

[Matt McGuire]

Donovans careeer numbers are pretty nice, with having 1 year with an amazing reciever. manning has played with Harrision and wayne for the most part, and throw in Dallas Clark. So, Manning does have better targets.

And a better OL, and in a weaker divison...

[schmidty]

yea i mean he's venting and didnt need to complain the way he did, but the facts are that the other QB's have better teams bulit around them. Im talking Manning, Brady, Palmer. Offensive teams might i add too. I think Mcnabb has plenty left in his tank. Weather its with the Eagles or another team. Palmer has looked amazing the year after the same energy that Mcnabb had.

[Walter]

yea i mean he's venting and didnt need to complain the way he did, but the facts are that the other QB's have better teams bulit around them. Im talking Manning, Brady, Palmer. Offensive teams might i add too. I think Mcnabb has plenty left in his tank. Weather its with the Eagles or another team. Palmer has looked amazing the year after the same energy that Mcnabb had.

McNabb has had better weapons than Brady ever had prior to this year. I'll take Terrell Owens over Deion Branch.

[Walter]

Also, I can't believe McNabb said Manning hasn't been criticized. Prior to last season, all everyone said about Manning is that he can't win the big one.

[schmidty]

That's true....but how would you compare Brady's o-line to Don's o-line? I think the Pats o-line has been clearly better over the years

[Walter]

Prior to this season, the Eagles have been known to have one of the better offensive lines in the NFL.

[schmidty]

But were they AS good as the pats?

[Matt McGuire]

But were they AS good as the pats?

Slightly better.

[schmidty]

i do not agree that they were slightly better at all! I think the pats o-line was better than the eagles and still are....how/why would u say that the pats o-line was better the eagles?

[Matt McGuire]

I'll take Tra Thomas over Matt Light anyday.

Shawn Andrews could be the best right guard in the NFC.
The white guy is good at RT forgot his name off the top of my head.

Pats line is very good, but wasn't as elite as the Eagles over the past 4 years.