2008 NFL Mock Draft Updated -11/17

[Walter]

http://walterfootball.com/draft2008.php

[bills_red]

20. Early Doucet

"Malcolm Kelly's talent will not be. Kelly, at 6-4, 217, is the perfect complement to the lightning-quick "

huh??

[giantsfanmike]

Not too bad, Walter. We need as many playmakers as possible to challenge Dallas and Hardy would help give us that. However I'd like to see us pick up a cornerback in the second. Fluellen I'm not sure would be a great pick. The Giants drafted Jay Alford last year in the 3rd and I feel they may be grooming him for the task as being a pass-rusher from the middle. I would like the Giants to draft a pass catching runningback in the third, or if there is none be bold and draft a QB who is a game manager and tough mentally.

[Walter]

20. Early Doucet

"Malcolm Kelly's talent will not be. Kelly, at 6-4, 217, is the perfect complement to the lightning-quick "

huh??

Good catch, I was planning on putting Kelly there, but copy-pasted it into the wrong place.

[Walter]

Not too bad, Walter. We need as many playmakers as possible to challenge Dallas and Hardy would help give us that. However I'd like to see us pick up a cornerback in the second. Fluellen I'm not sure would be a great pick. The Giants drafted Jay Alford last year in the 3rd and I feel they may be grooming him for the task as being a pass-rusher from the middle. I would like the Giants to draft a pass catching runningback in the third, or if there is none be bold and draft a QB who is a game manager and tough mentally.

That's pretty interesting. Are you giving up on Eli Manning?

[candyman82]

That's pretty interesting. Are you giving up on Eli Manning?

Honestly, the only thing keeping Manning in the league is his last name.

[giantsfanmike]

That's pretty interesting. Are you giving up on Eli Manning?

Hmmm not totally, his inconsistency is infuriating though and he needs pushed.

[candyman82]

If he wasn't Peytons brother, he'd already have been labeled a bust

[Walter]

If he wasn't Peytons brother, he'd already have been labeled a bust

True. But then again, if his name were Eli Brown, he wouldn't have been drafted so highly. Maybe second round, late first.

[candyman82]

But also, to play devils advocate to myself, why did Jordan Palmer go so late and then get cut?

[bills_red]

But also, to play devils advocate to myself, why did Jordan Palmer go so late and then get cut?

Because Eli was a big prospect Jordan was not

[candyman82]

Because Eli was a big prospect Jordan was not

Did Eli deserve to be such a big prospect?

[Walter]

Well, Eli Manning isn't untalented. He's just not as good as people thought he was. Jordan Palmer just wasn't any good.

[bills_red]

Did Eli deserve to be such a big prospect?

Yes I think so.

[candyman82]

I didn't like him on draft day, and I think he still plays like a rookie four seasons later